Carruthers: Animal Subjectivity

Peter Carruthers: Animal Subjectivity
____Replies to Critics: Explaining Subjectivity

Managing Editors: Colin Allen & Ann Wolfe

The Critics

Larry Shapiro: Saving the Phenomenal
Michael Lyvers: Who Has Subjectivity?
Mark A. Krause & Gordon M. Burghardt: Access to Another Mind: Naturalistic Theories Require Naturalistic
Derek Browne: Carruthers on the Deficits of Animals
Paola Cavalieri & Harlan B. Miller: Automata, Receptacles, and Selves
Eric Saidel: Consciousness Without Awareness
William G. Lycan: A Response to Carruthers' "Natural Theories of Consciousness"
William S. Robinson: A Theory of Phenomenal Consciousness?
Josh Weisberg: Active, Thin and Hot! An Actualist Response to Carruthers' Dispositionalist HOT View
Robert W. Lurz: A Defense of First-Order Representationalist Theories of Mental-State Consciousness